US District Judge Christina Snyder, appointed by President Bill Clinton, ruled the state law  discriminates against federal law enforcement, as it allowed state police to wear masks to conceal their identities while preventing federal law enforcement from doing the same.

However, she rejected the Trump administration's argument that the ICE agents needed to wear masks to be protected from doxxing, in a 30-page opinion Monday.

"The Act treats federal law enforcement officers differently than similarly situated state law enforcement officers," Snyder concluded.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed the No Secret Police Act in September 2025, only referencing federal, city and county law enforcement, but not including state law enforcement.

Snyder upheld a separate state law, "No Vigilantes Act," which Newsom signed at the same time, requiring all law enforcement officers operating in California to visibly display identification that includes their agency.

The judge suggested an altered law could withstand constitutional scrutiny.

"The court finds that these acts serve the public interest by promoting transparency, which is essential for accountability and public trust," Snyder wrote.

"Moreover, the Court finds no cognizable justification for law enforcement officers to conceal their identities during their performance of routine, non-exempted law enforcement functions and interactions with the general public." Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here

State Sen. Scott Wiener, a Democrat who authored the mask ban, said he would propose legislation adding state law enforcement to the law, Politico reported.  

Fred Lucas is chief news correspondent and manager of the Investigative Reporting Project for The Daily Signal.

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

Report: Parents Remain Essential to Instilling Authentic Faith in Next Generation

Who Is Counseling Our Children?

Supreme Court Vacates Biden-Era Decision Outlawing Gas Stoves, Water Heaters

California Election: Our Republic in the Balance

Belfast Burns as Protests Turn Violent after Sudanese Migrant's Brutal Knife Attack Leaves Man Partially Blind

Texas Teen Gets 35 Years in Fatal Track Meet Stabbing

House Democrats Join Republicans to Defeat Lebanon War Powers Resolution, in Surprisingly Bipartisan Response

US Retaliates with Strikes on Iran after Regime Downs US Helicopter; Future of Ceasefire Uncertain

'I Still Have a Dream' – MLK Jr.'s Niece Rejects SPLC's Hate-Mongering in Powerhouse Testimony

Michigan Town Bans Church From Holding Worship Services: Lawsuit

Cleveland Clinic to Provide $2M for Detransition Care, Won't Perform Sex-Change Procedures for Minors

'Not Above the Law': VP Vance Refers New Fraud Allegations against Tim Walz to DOJ

Confirmed: Gov Tim Walz, AG Keith Ellison Knew for 6 YEARS of Rampant MN Fraud But Said Nothing in Order to 'Keep Somali Votes'

Republican Candidate Steve Hilton Advances in California Governor's Primary Race

Rick Scott: Late LA Mayor Race Results Prove SAVE America is Necessary

Socialist Raman Defeats Spencer Pratt in LA Mayor Race with Last-Minute Vote Surge

The US Will 'Respond' to Iran Downing Army Chopper; Ceasefire in Question

Who Are the 13 Patriots Honored in Freedom Plaza?

The Left Couldn't Pause the Politics for One Lousy Day for 'The Great American State Fair'

One Player Refuses to Wear 'Pride' Hat During LA Dodgers' LGBT Night